
Originally Posted by
Marrone
Really, this is just the medicine RPGuild needs. It wont like it, and it might refuse it, but you know it works when you feel an initial distaste towards it. It indicates a need to actually work on creating a serious miliue that invokes creativity. Speaking of which, you might want to consider this aspect:
To me in my Sci-Fi Dungeon & Dragon RolePlays, the contribution of a characters past as well as any additional information a player wishes to invest into the project, is critical to expanding the depth of the story. The host can only go so far in creating the atmosphere; I believe it might be important for the host to also create an environment that's malleable enough for other players to play with and meld new ideas into, as long as it is appropriately canonical. But in light of this, I think there either just needs to be a rewording or just another mindset when regarding this point: Plot suggestions.
Plot suggestions, I assume, come from the other players. So in this, there wouldn't need to be another pesky policy (since brevity is best, I assure you!) but perhaps rewording to make the statement more broad. But of course, it's up to you to weigh the need for this. If that ends up not working, for any reason, I don't see any reason to change it. I think it might focus too much on the host, and while that's certaintly important, the players who accompany the topic creator are the ones who enliven the environment, so further concepts and ideas might be beneficial to create a better experience.
Additionally, I would suggest creating two policy-based questionnaires: one for short-hand, the other for long. It is invaluable to have a much more brief version, especially concerning the very early upbringings to a role play (since too much questions can be daunting), however, upon the projects dawn I believe a more verbose and interesting range of questions that aim to strengthen the colors of the plot will help bring a bud to flower. Of course, if that just doesn't seem plausible, or if it doesn't ring true to your heart, then I believe you shouldn't do it at all. These rules aim to help, not recede, and I think you do a fine job at that.