Reply With QuoteCan't say I know a lot about Ancient China, let alone their generals, so I have no idea. Muhammad does have a reputation for being an effective military commander though, which does kind of explain the quick spread of his ideas within his lifetime.
I was just thinking about Muhammed's reputation as a field commander and military leader, I heard tell he was a genius, so I wondered, what would happen if Guan Yu were to possess 30,000 Shu Han troops against Muhammed's armies, would he be able to conquer Muhammed's armies?
Can't say I know a lot about Ancient China, let alone their generals, so I have no idea. Muhammad does have a reputation for being an effective military commander though, which does kind of explain the quick spread of his ideas within his lifetime.
WHO IS DEADLIEST?
I am so sorry.
My guess would it would largely depend on who has the homefield advantage, due to China being quite different from the Middle East and adapting different tactics to their environments, as well as how well trained and disciplined their troops were.
A special thanks to Vanquished for the sig!
And another special thanks to Tick for the avatar!
Roleplays I GM
The Elder Scrolls: Vengeance of the Deep (Co-GMing with O|NoSoul)
Mass Effect: Nova (Collaborative GM project among all players)
Just assume that Guan Yu is there .. . Muhammed is there. It might be a desert enironment, maybe over by Pakistan somewhere.Originally Posted by Dervish
Posting Permissions
