Well, here's how it went. I made a 2/3 coin toss, heads meaning I keep Artist and tails meaning I delete him. I got 1 head and 2 tails. So now I can either create a new character or I can use Michelle.

Famotill, you are the GM, so you should probably have some say in this. I am fine with either using Michelle, or creating a new character, which I actually have a few ideas for. If you think that I should make the decision then ok.