I'm sorry, as I left this RP I probably should leave it alone.
I just can't help but get a slightly annoyed feeling and I am just going to say them no matter whether they make me unliked or not:
Could you please refrain from calling people's character sheets 'not good enough'? You don't know how much effort someone puts into something, and not good enough is quite derogatory. I know this might be just a form thing, but perhaps phrases like 'Doesn't match the lore' are way less offensive, and actually describe the problem better.
Also, people (or I dont know if I talk for others or only myself so let us just say 'I' instead) usually put some effort in thinking of their sheet. While it is okay to make people rewrite parts, if this happens too often, people will get annoyed (once again, just replace with I if others dont agree). To avoid that, you should think of all rules before people have already started. First you tell people that they can have powerful weapons, then suddenly they can't have those, first you have pets, suddenly those didnt exist in you past etc. I guess it might seem like it doesn't matter that much, but people write back stories that contain them, and it might be really hard for them to rewrite it countless times.

So yeah, I'm sorry for butting in on something that no longer is my business, but I couldn't help it.