[quote=Neobullseye]
In other words, a completely nameless and personalityless Player Avatar is not okay.
[/quote]

And would that also extend to named but voiceless characters like Gordon Freeman? Or how about named and voiced characters but who lack a fixed story like Shepard (yeah, he still fights the Reapers and went through the main events, but everything else like how those fights ended is up to the player)?