Which setting should I use?

2. Doodlequest, Dark Skies: I've voiced my interest in this, and if Jansen's character sheets and stats are still kicking around, I'm totally for it. :D

How should I run the game, story wise?

2. Sandbox Game: Dark Skies kind of goes well with the sandbox. After all, it's a survival thing, so working together to survive a world we don't know what's in store is kind of super appealing. I'm sure our own personal plot will arise from this, anyways!

How should combat go

1. Simple Combat: Keeps the pace moving up; will prevent complications and the scene from being locked down in the same scene for ungodly amounts of time. I think the simplicity of previous doodlequests kept things fun and moving along.