Krein said
For some reason I can never get that into anime. I don't even know why, the premises of the shows are typically interesting but I'm never really grabbed enough to really enjoy them or look forward to another episode. It might be the art style... it sometimes makes the characters look too flawless if that makes any sense.There are actually three animes I'd watch though. Pokemon, Yugioh, and Megaman NT Warrior.
Funnily enough, those are anime I've never gotten into. Well, besides Pokemon. Everyone has a Pokemon phase, I'm pretty sure of it. Yugioh kind of rubs me the wrong way, for some reason...
I tend to have the same problem with most anime, style-wise. Even in Madoka I forced myself to accept the artsies only because it was part of what made the deconstruction impacting, somehow. If you want an anime where the characters don't look all that perfect, you could look into Paranoia Agent. I've never actually watched it, but apparently it's good in a mind-bendy way.
I don't watch much anime these days. Just watched too much at once so I got sick of it. Madoka and Attack on Titan have been the only anime I've watched in 6 or so years. Aside from movies that is. *rambleramble*