[quote=Grey Star]I'm sorry to say this but the Judge is outright vetoed because a lot of his abilities results in autohits for the most part.[/quote]

i knoooow it suuuucks

I anticipated that this might happen, especially considered that his actual in-game techniques are annoyingly overpowered for our purposes- The words 'Aneurysm Rupture' and 'Immediate Sclerosis' make an appearance in his final battle.

I'm not giving up on the Judge quite yet, though. For one thing, OFF's graphics are quite simple, so battles are mostly text-based. We can interpret the Judge's ability however we like, especially as we only ever see it happening in a small room, at point blank, against a single target. For a start, we can adjust that to make his bodily seizures a contact effect- Let's say he has to drag around his back legs to come within range of biting or scratching a target to begin dealing damage. With what means he induces the effects are also left unknown, so let's say he has to use physical contact repeatedly to build up a 'connection' to his target to begin using his ability, and this connection can be broken if he himself takes injury or is separated from a target. 
More importantly, the full extent of the Judge's powers are only ever seen when the player is actively controlling him. When playing the Batter during the same encounter, the fight goes exactly as can be expected between a cat and a bat-wielding sportsman (unless you're underlevelled, in which case it's still much easier than other boss battles). So assuming the player stopped playing OFF (the Judge is autonomous again in the credits cutscenes), we're at liberty to take away as much of his actual danger as we like- Let's say that, unaided, his blindness is a momentary blur that only gradually grows into a loss of vision if he keeps working at it.

So in short, his paralysis/poison/sensory deprivation/stroke could be written as longer-term effects that needs to be built up and maintained by close contact, which in practice rarely lasts long enough to become more than stiffness/nausea/confusion/a severe headache. Would such edits do?