[quote=kapuchu]
If I have to be honest, it feel like you just don't want Amaretto to get the insight knowledge he's after, and does a bit of meta-gaming by having him refuse because you, as a player, knows it's a fake. I know you probably don't, but I can't help but feel that way :/ Sorry.
[/quote]

to be fair, Scalpel is insanely paranoid, that was one of his founding traits, and I'd be damned if I said I wasn't a little unintentionally biased in favour of Ammy getting nowhere with this, as technically I wasn't planning on Thea knowing about what the Doctor was up to at ALL, you threw me a curveball with your little Nightmare pony and I had to run with it.

Also I need justification for you not simply busting in an incinerating me, it might not seem fair, but then I am not playing an all powerful deity now am I?