I do have one thing to say though. Wouldn't a small-group Anime club be consider Otaku culture and be shunned by various sects of Japanese culture? If that's the case, shouldn't the characters, being nervous about joining, come in at a rate of about once a day (sparsely) compared to all of the characters coming into the club all at once?

No, I'm not just typing this to get extra time for my CS, though it would most certainly help.