[quote=VerifyinTr1gIDs]
Detention for David for using an extension charm in a compartment, but nothing for Gary for punching a muggle? I want Amelia as my teacher :DThe oddities of using the verb, "read" without a subject. Is it a command to Feisty-Pants? Is it past-tense for you? Is it a command to everyone? The world may never know~
[/quote]

She hasn't decided on a punishment for Gary yet.

However, she is a fan of one being able to defend themselves.