We need judges for a non-ranked battle where they are our characters, not the people controlling them. For example, I could have a bloodthirsty idiot guy as one of the judges and have him judge the fight accordingly, making hilariously bad choices on who should win based on his bias. Actually, that would be an interesting fight mechanic to freshen things up. You can see in what way the judges are biased so have your characters change their fighting style accordingly.