[quote=@ImportantNobody]
<Snipped quote by Vordak>

The fighters. The spartan would run circles around my character trying to learn how to properly fight in melee.
[/quote]

I don't think it will work out that well - after all, it is our knowledge that this fight is meant to put to test, and it may not necessarily fit the skills our characters supposedly have. I'd say that Imaginary has the character with most training, while you have the character with least - but for all i know, you both may have an equal level of insight into the workings of close-ranged combat, which would contradict the context your characters' backgrounds provide.