To be fair, if the player wanted complete control/creative freedom, wouldn't they just write instead of do a tabletop rpg? Maybe I'm splitting hairs. I could change it, but I don't know to what, and I'd rather see how it plays out, ya' know? At least for now? I could always give an alternate formula.

(Well, a lot of things are irrelevant to a player character, like if they miss their attacks or not)

I can see that, but again, I sort of want to try this first, yeah?