[quote=@Skallagrim]
<Snipped quote by ImportantNobody>

Clearly you don't disagree since you stated that apples being thrown by trees is different that an occasional haphazard melee attack. We are not talking about being slapped by a tree or something along those lines, we are talking about the disruptive influences having an impact on the fight. 
[/quote]

I guess Rilla is the one taking it further. It seemed like you'd also be against environments being much of a factor at all, which would include things like trees that attack. Stuff like that would be based on player skill and strategy to manipulating your opponent into getting attacked by the environment. This is entirely different than an environment that spawns meteors to target people's faces or something, which doesn't involve player skill to get their opponent hit and truly would be the environment attacking you like an npc. I'd be fine with an occasional battle in such an environment but certainly not tournaments.