The actual ending decision isn't as important to me as actually having Reaper join up with everybody, so if, in the end, everyone wants to split the deal, then that's totally fine. But unless Reaper's first inclination is (rather than just trying to get his own job done under duress and sniper fire) to immediately try and make peace with everyone, then there might be some problems. I don't want to make decisions for anybody's character, but a possible solution is just for Reaper to stay alive until the shooting with the Trolls is finished and then everyone could potentially have a conversation with the CDs themselves as collateral. Recluse would still be up in the ceiling looking down a scope, so Reaper could be the team's quick access to an easy escape. Reaper dispels the magical trap on the CDs and the team forms a temporary truce until the job is over (agreeing to split the profits or something, it doesn't matter at that point.) If that avenue is appealing to everyone, we can go with that, but until I hear whether it's satisfactory, I'll keep thinking on it.