This [i]is[/i] a casual roleplay. I don't see why wanting quality is a bad thing. It's just criticism.
We put work into roleplays and hope they even last long enough so our work would pay off. I don't think it's wrong to analyze a character sheet and say something is out of place. It helps others see what they should not do for their own characters, as well.
It's time worth spent editing if you really want to be in the roleplay.