[@Aurrorian]

Where'd you hear that rule? At least on RPGuild, its the unspoken rule to do exactly that when someone presents a broken character or powerplay/puppets others. If people didn't do that, you'd see a lot of god-tier characters running around in RPs doing whatever they want without restraint and people fighting OOC about it. Its all for balance and to keep everything equal for everyone else.

Besides, if you weren't allowed to do that stuff, then the GM and co-GM concept would be useless :p 

EDIT: About your new points, most people prefer not to play an instigator since it generally means being a dick to others which more often than not doesn't rub well OOC.

If you have anything to say about Alec, I'm more than willing to listen ^^