You're twisting it around. Batman is feared as possibly the most dangerous man in the DC Universe. Still he is only human. All of the heroes who are his allies respect him and know he's their comrade but even still they each character regardless of who they are have the fear of facing him because they know what he is capable of just like even if it doesn't seem like it he does have fears of his own. 

Now I know it might not be a crippling fear. It's not for most. it's just a fear that's there... You know you fear him... It'll have some effect, but it's not like you'll just just become unable to move or anything... But seriously dude...

You're GM made a decision and you kind of went against it... 

If not for that I probably wouldn't have needed to get involved... Come on Stry. You're better than that.