[quote=@ImportantNobody]
[@MelonHead]

I like the idea.

For stuff like that it also might be best just to plan the battle out for a story and allow characters to fall for stuff, but if we wanted an actual battle from it where you can win or lose, that may be the best way to do it.
[/quote]

Yeah that would be an option, but what I'm talking about is almost the complete antithesis of this, where the OOC is almost entirely removed from the experience, complete immersion in the RP if you will. As there is a judge present by necessity as well the potential for fighting and arguing would be diminished to the point of almost a non-factor.

And yes, the main issue would be the difficulty in assembling three dedicated individuals, but I do think it would be an amazing experience. If any two people were willing to try it I'd happily play the role of the DM/Judge for a test run. Might need some more thought but I'll definitely be working on this for a while.

Also LeeRoy, you owe me a post as your giant rhino-lizard.