[quote=@MissCapnCrunch]
[i]Hear me out, cause I'm gross- but what if the killer is called the Alligator cause he bites off a chunk of each victim? [/i]
[/quote]

That's leave too much evidence in the victims, anyone half decent in forensics would be able to get his DNA from the bodies. 


Speaking of co-mastermind, how about we PM about the killer from now on, just to keep the mystery alive :P