@Jbcool Eh, I understand. It would likely be out of place for would-be Sauron followers to align themselves in a fellowship as this. But out of curiosity; would it differ if it is a disillusioned Black Númenórean? In contrast to Orcs, all men are (kind off) redeemable. Their source of evil is more their lack of strength. (Isildur and Boromir.)

Edit: You know the 2011 'War in the North' game? I liked it. This RP concept reminds me a bit of it. Like this RP the story's generally loyal to the lore and tropes.