[@User] That's more or less what I was going for here as well, although I'd probably give everyone information as soon as they reached a certain point in the story, and it'd be up to them as to how to proceed. For example, I'm planning on keeping the identity of the "monster" (the thing that killed everyone at the lab) a secret until the group actually reached the lab and found the first body. After that, everyone would be free to interact with this information however they please.