Well, that took longer than I expected, but I finally posted. Apologies if it's a bit long, just didn't have it in me to chop it up into two posts.

[quote=@Jbcool]
I haven't, but what would you prefer? 

Narrative is always easier, but I could do a mix of the two - you write about going for a strike, I roll to see if it's successful etc; it's just what 'the people' want, really.
[/quote]

I'm fine with both. Personally, I enjoy dice rolls because they offer an element of luck, which can sometimes foil even the most well-detailed plan. It's an interesting challenge from a writing perspective and makes it more realistic. And I say that as the guy who usually gets all the 1's :lol 

The counterpoint would be that luck can fuck you over completely. Like, my character, who isn't much of a fighter, can get lucky and have some high rolls and be successful in combat. However, Baranor for example, a seasoned warrior, may have a streak of bad luck and end up failing in situations you wouldn't expect considering his skills. I guess you can offset that by adding some modifiers, but then the whole thing risks becoming too "game-y" /shrug

Anyway, I'm easy, up to you guys.