[@balthazar007] I'm going to have to take you up on that offer if it comes down to it.

However, I do rather like the current system because it benefits people who are very active online while not exactly at the expense of those who aren't, so I'm going to make another pitch for the collaborative doc. 

Google docs, shared with the "official" members -- members that are guaranteed to know what they're doing. You can own the doc but give the other members editing rights, and then give the general pubic permission to comment or just give individual users permission to comment. The "official members" can check their posts, and if someone approves of the comment they can just edit it into the doc. In a different doc if need be. You can have an "official doc" and a "side doc" with shared rights.

Make the requirement that everyone has to keep track of their Pokemon/TP/CP at the end of every post in a hider starting pronto (since most people are already doing it) so you can double check more easily if need be. But I think this self-governing thing works fine.