[@Catchphrase] You gotta admit that it would be a rather entertaining series of events, just imagine the two of them finding out that the other is also a cook for there perspective crew and Jack, wanting nothing more than to cause trouble, starts saying that he could out cook Alphie. Alphie, wanting to be better than a pirate challenges Jack to a cooking competition. To which both crews are completely baffled but go along with it anyway despite not liking it very much.