[quote=@Crimson Raven]
<Snipped quote by DearTrickster>

To my knowledge he was an simply an immortal werewolf, who gained magic when he stole the witch's eye. He was not classified as a witch, and I believe they never referred to him as one when they read his soul.
[/quote]

Yes I think you might be right. He pissed off the witches and from the eye gained witch-like magic.