Throwing in my two cents as a mostly lurking member since pre-Guildfall. 

First thank you [@Buddha] for making this thread as well as others who contributed. I've sort of skimmed over everything so here's my thoughts:

1. As someone who roleplays 18+ content, yes please lets add either a tag or a 18+ subforum of some kind. In a pure organization level this would be great. 

2. Allowing more tags in general would be nice as well. I have a very open and vast interest in a variety of genres and 5 is way too limiting. I literally do everything but Horror, Arena, Nation RP, and Historical. That leaves a lot of genres with not enough tags to cover it

3. I don't agree with merging Nation, Arena, and Tabletop with anyone, including each other. While they might not be as active, they don't clutter enough to be an issue (I can easily browse using my [i]phone[/i] if that's enough of a indication) and they need visibility since they're not as popular as other purely play by post roleplays. 

4. I'm down with more mod visibility and more mod action. I have personally just ignored and quietly bitched about certain behaviors that I felt broke the rules but didn't report because I didnt feel like any action would have been taken. It's nothing personal against the mods, as I like most of them as people in general, but it is what it is. 

I don't personally have answers for exactly how to make this work but I figured another voice chiming in might help convince some these are issues that need work. 

EDIT:

I'm so desperate for a better PM system. I have loads of PMs just cluttering my inbox, some I want to save, some I want to delete but there's so many doing them one at a time is tedious and not worth it. 

[i]Pleaaase[/i]