I'd like you to keep in mind in terms of days, and weeks Fate styled roleplays shouldn't last more than two to three weeks at the very most, and that day to day combative fights matter. Knocking out a player, or sealing them for a day is a big deal remember that Artoria Saber was missing her primary sword arm for her second fight with caster, and Diarmuid had to step in to assist her otherwise she'd probably have lost, or at least been injured even more so. So healing preparation time is not something black, and or Red will have a lot of time of. Flight is also a big deal in fates. Flight ranged heroes can sometimes neg certain servants. Take my own Lancelot since I can't reveal Red's roster. Lancelot's only out to flight is unleashing Arondight as a beam instead of Overload. 

I'd also like you to keep in mind that his only canonical prototype phantasms are
Harpe
Winged sandals
Mantle
Mirror-shield
Bellerophon - It is the same as Medusa's Bellerophon, a Pegasus-handling bridle

So the scythe, and the bag shouldn't even be in there in the first place.

EDIT: Need to get my head together the thing you named the scythe is the harpe so just the bag really.