@FalloutJackYeah, the Canon of the 3D games is a bit in the air, while Many consider it way more Canon before Other M... in the Prime games, what was Canon was Meta Ridley. Dark Samus, Aether (Which was a planet.)
Phaze, and the Other Alien Hunters.
Rundas could manipulate ice(It was not tech based.), there was a Shape Shifter (Also not tech) who could perfectly Mimic Samus' suit.
There was another Hunter I believe who could manipulate machines.
There were Aurora Units -- Federation Mother Brains, who were ironically very friendly.
Hell, the Galactic Federation does shit good for once.
There was the Phazon, which gradually corrupted Samus over time.
Honestly, you should check those games out. Like, even if you just watch a recap of the story beats, it would be good.
Prime honestly did all the things that Dark Souls was praised for, years before it was a thing. Had great world building, and visual story telling.
____________
The Collective was just a purposed idea to help give a sense of more of outside the federation, with humane efforts.
But if I have to be objective here, and get back to topic, mostly so we can get to agreed upon things, and get to the posting in the thread itself... I purpose something we could probably agree on.
First, in many ways, I agree with SimpleWriter here. The Neutral nature of the Tribunal, and his personality traits would be able to pose objectively sound objectives based on a situation and position, and while in his shoes, he is not the Front Man in a fight, we have strong fighters to fulfill that Role.
A Space Marine could cover the Front and Flanks, where we have raw power through Kaze and his general durability.
Vale seems like a capable ranged Gunner, and scout, but she isn't who you'd want in the front either, Good Suppressing to covering fire.
Vekt seems more sound as the demolitionist as he is.
From Cas' position, he seems like he would be better if he was in the middle of a formation given the support tools he has.
Amber seems like she would be a good Science Officer -- someone who handles forensics, to which her and Cassius could talk in terms to update others in a simple, yet informative way before proceeding in a situation if they have a calm moment where they can breathe.
On top of that, Amber is a good Spotter with her Artifice, Amy -- her AI.
This just objectively makes the most sense, where Zen would also seem to be there situationally based on what I understand.
At the end, there would still be a spot for democracy in which they would need to decide on some sound things if a situations calls on it.
Is this all agreeable?