[quote=@Wayward]
🤔

Is there any way I can reasonably play into the reluctant hero trope on this one? 
[/quote]

Honestly, It would be possible. My big issue is that reluctant heroes tend to come across as overly edgey. You can certainly put together a character, I won't stop you. But I would say that at the very least, they must have been a part of the Coven beforehand.