[quote=@Guardian Angel Haruki]
She studies his surprised reaction and listens to his...well, not quite so official demand for their identities. She retorts to the man, borrowing a line from an enigmatic character she once read, keeping her tone even and calm, "Don't you know it's rude to demand our identities without introducing yourself first?" 
[/quote]

The man lays his hand on his gun and flips open the holster's latch, but for now, the gun stays where it is. He does, however, take a couple of steps back from the three of you, and the side of his body with the gun is turned away from you; if he does draw, he'll be in a good shooting stance.

"Well," he says. Clears his throat. Looks back and forth at the four figures in the diner. "Ok."

A cacophonous sound comes from the kitchen, metal crashing against metal, followed by a distant screech.

The man takes a deep breath. 

"I'm Agent Ray Simonsen, IDLN. I know you haven't heard of us, but here's my badge--" As he speaks, Agent Simonsen reaches into his jacket, then freezes suddenly. "Um. My badge." He reaches in the other coat pocket--awkwardly, as he refuses to take his hand off of his gun. Checks his pants pocket. Frowns.

"Well, I'm with the IDLN. We're an agency responsible for handling sensitive cases, like the one breaking all the dishes back there. What you're doing right now is obstruction of justice. I ought to arrest all four of you, but I've got other stuff that's more important to deal with, so if you all just get going to whatever halloween party you were headed to, I'll look the other way this time."