I agree. Mary Sues annoy me.

I kind of agree with Mr_Pink. I'd like a renegade because Shepard would realistically have to look like a bad guy now and then since he/she winds up making tough decisions a lot. Can't please everyone. The Unity, however, is just trying to help out (until we write something in that makes us look bad). 

Besides, this is war, and although I often don't have the heart to hit renegade options in the game I think in real life Shepard would. Maybe our Shepard will be a mix of both, leaning a little toward the Renegade side?