[quote=Shy]
The funniest was probably "hunt down and kill whoever stole the stick then go put it back in its place." I laughed.
[/quote]

I'm amazed that wasn't accepted as a legit answer just for that fact. (No, this wasn't my answer.) 

I'm not really convinced of anyone's guilt at this point. Jorick makes some good points, but I hesitate to believe that Shy would give us such an [i]obvious[/i] clue in Vordak at the first murder scene. Nor do I believe Svenn did it, his actions are shady but it seems more like his character is just really amped to win the game the legal way. 

If someone can win me over to one side or another, my vote may actually count for something.