And by the way... I'm not the one wanting to apply real world logic to a supernatural RP where Vampires, fauns, witches and wizards exist.
There's a little bit of a problem here. It's not because it's fantasy that it has to be completely insane (otherwise no one could understand anything), nor that everything has to follow the standard stereotypes (otherwise all the Teachers would be villains since all of them are from shady backgrounds like witches, vampires, spider monsters, etc).
We don't want to force anything to your character, nor anyone else's, what seems to be the issue is that you don't understand that we are in charge of the "Nature" and decide how it works regardless of your character's view of it.
Again, Lilac is free to see the world however she wants. It doesn't mean that the world works like she sees it, though.