excuse me for using this OOC for complaining about something with an other RP, but I really dont think its fair and wanted to know what you guys think.
the GM of that rp has quite a lot of interested people so a few spots, now there were a few that came open so I made the CS
used one of my personal favorites, at first all that was wrong was the history being to short
fixed that.
2 weeks later I finally got a reply: she is not loving my char at all, so he cant be used.
its not that I can change anything, no have to make a brand new one (making me feel like she is hating it)
so yeah, i quit with that one, the rp sounded great, but by the time I made a new one and 2 weeks have gone by again or something, all spots will be filled, not worth the time, Especially if our tastes are so bad
BUT here is the thing that bugs me the most
I picked that char with the sole reason that he fitted the rp perfectly, its an X-men based rp, he lives by the X-men/ spiderman code and wants to be a hero and all
she hates it
I think if you hate it, you hate it, BUT dont go kicking people's char's out after they took so much time in and waited so long for a responce about it when its just your personal feeling
I look at chars I have to judge as a GM if they fit and are not OP and all
BUT if a see a char or something that I personally dont like, I dont go say, "I dont love your characters concept so I cant accept it, if you want to join you have to make a new character sheet with a new character"
no, I think, its not my chara taste but I am not the one behind it
for example, the Octopus idea from skyvard, when I read it I was kind of thinking like, , not my taste, but its not my char anyway, so yeah, looked if it fitted and all, looking for its good points and power traits, it was all good and now I am reading how Skyvard is in action I am starting to like it, still not my taste but I dont have to play with it so why would that matter
sorry if this upset you Rocket, just being honest and like I said, its just not my taste but as I am seeing it in the rp I am getting the idea and its actually great
sometime you just need to see someone in action before you get a good idea of the char or race
I think all of you have had such an experience while running a rp
you see someone make a char that you dont like in general, but if its not in conflict, why would it matter, that is there taste so just role with it and see if it can make things more fun and better in general (like with Skyvard, he is turning out great if you ask me, but before he was in action it was not my taste, its perfect example, taste means nothing if the others can make it good)
some people even go so far as to make a char that everyone hates
so why would that matter
I wont be in that rp anymore, if I am forced to play to the gm's taste and she hates one of my favorites, then its over for me with that rp
if she had an other reason like, he wont fit the setting or he is overpowered, or just a little thing that can be changed, fine
but saying I need to drop my char because she is not loving it, then I dont agree with
then you might as well play an rp with just your own made char's