Raineh Daze said Well, it's more that no-one can become a Servant for guns, because skill with them isn't all that impressive (the only Servant from modern times cheated and made a deal with the world, is actually pretty weak for it, doesn't have an NP proper), so no-one can become a Servant for guns. If Zero Berserker is more dangerous with a sword than any type of firearm, guns aren't overpowered at all.
Mmmkay, not sure if that's a yes or no. Regardless, Ned's distinction wasn't really for his skill with a gun. He wasn't a famous sniper or anything like that. It was more that he and his buddies stuck it to the man in a manner that few people had done back then and he had a pretty cool final stand.
Raineh Daze said More bothered by a boost to NP strength if someone represents an 'oppressive' ideal, because conditions like that are more or less fulfilled with the sort of logic Servants run on.
I can live without that. How does removing that detail and decreasing the boost to a single + for the background thing sound?
Raineh Daze said Also, I think Nature of a Rebellious Spirit should be a lower rank, since... you've got it high enough to counter the sort of Charisma to rule a country. He wasn't disruptive.
Yeah, I suppose you're right. In all honesty that skill was more for the flavour. The C and D ranks weren't outlined in the wiki, and the E rank... I'm not sure exactly how that works. Which rank would be more appropriate?