I will officially have to get back to you with your characters, and consult Tek about them. Though that's mostly because the bios don't really tell me who they are, they really just tell me the gimmick of the character. Which means I'm not really basing my acception off of whether I like the character or not, it's based on if I like the gimmick or not.
If you could perhaps put more backstory into the why, I'd be more than glad to accept. Why did Toby join the military? Tell me why Tyson loves animals with a little story. Tell me how flemeth got to be that way.
Without those crucial bits, I'm basing this entirely off of the gimmick that the character imposes, which I hate. Characters must feel like people, or they're just plot device cardboard cut-outs that have no reason other than to be "the goth kid" or "the military brat."
Ah, didn't notice the third one was The One's character. I'm willing to accept that, if, like I said, the why is somewhat explained. You can leave it open-ended, but why is a big part that makes characters. Also, if she's purely here to be a chaotic evil character to add more of a balance within the group, insanity is a really boring reason, so as long as she has a reason, we're good to go.