Avatar of babbysama
  • Last Seen: 3 mos ago
  • Joined: 11 yrs ago
  • Posts: 483 (0.12 / day)
  • VMs: 1
  • Username history
    1. babbysama 11 yrs ago

Status

User has no status, yet

Bio

Just a guy who wishes he could change his username

Most Recent Posts

I think it would be more prudent, at least on the first day, to adopt a more defensive posture. Have outriders and scouts harry the enemy and draw them in, where we can bang them up against our defenses and clamp down with some spirited cavalry maneuvers. Of course, assuming that Alaric is as able a tactician as we've heard, it's doubtful that this'd have any real effect; rather, we both need to send out feelers and see what the other is capable of. He'll be expecting a strong defense and deep entrenchment, which will make any aggressive moves we take all the more surprising. However, at least until we know the full extent of what we're up against, I don't think that sallying forth would be the wisest thing to do. It's not like on the first day much is going to get done anyway.
@MiddleEarthRoze Great! Excited to be a part of this.

I'll try and get a post up soonish.

What about a group effort in the start? Where we all plan out the first battle together and see who emerges as a favorite to become the Lord Comman- errr, leader for the next.


I like this idea.
@MiddleEarthRoze Sorry about the Mirkwood/Beleriand mixup, I must've just misread something (wrote it late at night lol).

As for the backstory thing, I see what you mean. I just thought that someone who would probably have figured so prominently in the whole "myth" of the War of the Ring (from the Rohirrim's perspective) and who was so close to the future king, to get shunned in such a big way and yet still to have a place of prominence in popular culture and consciousness might have stuck to Éothain's line a bit more readily than if it had been a different family; basically I'm trying to say that even good-natured people can be two-faced. Perhaps it could be that some son of Eorl reinforced the prejudice, and it just turned into a feud between the house of Eorl (which I'm assuming would still be the royal house in the Fourth Age) and the line of Éothain? Hopefully all of what I just said makes sense lol. I see your point though, I'll see if I can finesse it so that it makes a bit more sense.

As for the slavery thing, sorry for that, I didn't draw that from any source or anything. Would saying "servant" be more appropriate?

I'll go ahead and start making the changes you requested ASAP

EDIT: I did a bit of retooling and rephrasing to make it fit in with the changes, hope it works!
Perhaps we should just choose by random selection, drawing lots? Assuming that all of us are equally competent.
Sorry for taking so long to get it up, but here's my CS. Hope it's clear and lore-friendly enough. I might go back and make a few edits here and there as I wrote this kind of hastily, but I think the general gist is understandable.


I think that it'd be in Florian's character to volunteer as commander, but I'm not entirely sure as to my own capacities as a tactician. In most strategy games I play the long game, and focus more on defense. Might be good for this kind of thing but maybe someone else might be better for the first day.
@MiddleEarthRoze Great, I'll try and get a CS up by tomorrow!
Hi there.

I'm currently reading The Silmarillion and have been in a real Tolkien mood lately, so I'd love to participate if you still have spots open. I can't say I'm the most well versed in the legendarium besides having read the books (except for The Silmarillion, The Children of Hurin, The Unfinished Tales, etc.), but I'll do my best.

I'm thinking of making a character from Rohan since they have the best aesthetic tbh

If there's still a spot open I'd love to participate!
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet