EldritchOne

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

You sure you added that comment? cause I can't seem to find it.

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

kapuchu said
I sent you a link with the old character profile I had of him. I also added a comment in the top of the "Background" part which mentions the few things I changed about him since we started In Nominé.

Thanks, that'll clear up a lot.

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

kapuchu said
Anywho, Scalpel being paranoid is completely reasonable, I just wanted to be absolutely sure that you were aware of everything first :)

Well its not as if I am going to Metagame this, but there is certainly stuff I can still find out naturally, especially pre-attack records. Frankly I think it'd help a lot if I got a complete background on Amaretto rather than just vague statements, otherwise things that don't conform to your canon are likely going to pop up by accident.

Don't think this is me Metagaming however, I actually plan an extensive period of time of which Scalpel and Amaretto are going to be playing cat and mouse with each other, but neither of them however are going to go away from this unchanged, or perhaps not even with what they came for in the first place.

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

kapuchu said
Well, he could if you wanted him to, but at this point I feel like it'd be sort of meta gaming to do so. Also, what does he have to lose? Amaretto has just proven himself to have the artefact of a God, shown that he's willing to steal from one, all to get back what he lost. That should convince most anyone that he's telling the truth is he dares to go to such lengths just to get the chance to see the again. And even then, if just one of the maids end up as being "mindless," that's all he needs. ...Sorry if it seems like I'm trying to control the flow of events, but there is quite a lot of things to take into account here, so him just "suddenly" asking if Amaretto is telling the truth would seem a lot like "I don't want your character's plan to work, so I'm gonna ruin it with meta knowledge." Don't get me wrong, if Scalpel retains his immense paranoia and he does end up asking (provided all 3 are sane and have their memories), then I won't complain because it would make sense. I just really want to avoid meta-gaming to happen.

Thats fair enough, and I don't plan on metagaming my way into discrediting him, but you are missing one vital fact, Scalpel is investigating ALL of the people currently in contact with him. He is paranoid enough from experience to know when something is going to well for him and to question when and how his luck is going to turn, The fact that Amaretto seems brave enough to go against the gods either means he is stupid enough or mad enough to do so, it doesn't rationalise HOW he managed to get away with it, or WHY the gods aren't on his heels for it.

You have to take into account that even his closest associates don't even know what he is actually up to as well, Nokky knows its something big and world changing, but Scalpel has been keeping it a secret. Probably the only two people who know fully what Scalpel is actually up to is himself and to a lesser degree Honey, but both are going to pretty tight lipped about it because it's something that WILL get you killed, whether it be from an angry god or the inquisitors of Moon and Star.

Also another thing to be aware of, Scalpel is going to be running tests on these people, and one of these tests is going to be on how well they have retained their memories, he wants the best result for the prize he is about to claim, otherwise he is aware it could go south. If I was going to go through with one of these test myself however, the first thing I'd ask them was if they remembered their name. Furthermore the attack on Amaretto's distilleries doesn't seem to have been very quiet, there were doubtless onlookers or witnesses to its destruction, including those who actually attacked the place, people Scalpel can ask and investigate. Furthermore if there are any pictures of Amaretto's family, or records of who was in his household, or even newspapers, the whole thing could collapse very quickly simply because Amaretto has already lied to him about how many died in the first place.

Unless Thea is actively covering up as much as Scalpel is investigating, this case would be very easy to pull to pieces from a realistic standpoint. The simple fact being I can find out via means other than Metagaming. also I'd like to point out that you aren't the only person being targeted out of this, the Monolith meeting is essentially a deathtrap for instance if anything goes wrong, so he doesn't even trust Lens even though the meetings with her have been going quite cordially.

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

Sounds like the plan of Thea's will go swishy, unless Scalpel ever bothers to verify their identities by asking them once freshly awoken. :P

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

kapuchu said
Done xP ~300 words, I think. Coulda done better, but horrible day = less productivity <.<Edit:Just posted it into Wordcount.net... It's 300 words exactly :p

S'cool man.

Also won't he need a stand in for his wife and daughter? because last time I checked they were all alivey and stuff. :P

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

kapuchu said
*groan*Just got home. Haven't had such a bad day in I don't know how long... I'll get the post up soon-ish. Just don't expect it to be "perfect" or completely up to standards <.< Sorry

S'cool, don't sweat about it, I am sure it'll be fine, you can take another day or two if you want, I am sure we all can wait.

Worlds Collide - A Futuristic Fantasy RP

kapuchu said
Waiting a little on you here, Eldritch :)

Werking on it.

Waiting a little on you here, Kappa. :P

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

kapuchu said
Await my next post, or? <.<

Yes.

Equestria Divided: In Nominé - MLP RP

kapuchu said
Await my next post, or? <.<

Yes.