Yeah, definitely need professional help for your two characters XD There's going to be a lot of debate going on IC if any of the characters found out - as logical and methodical as it may seem. Tbh, it's not ironical when she's perfectly logical - considering that logic =/= emotions XD
Humans need emotions as much as logic in order to be human! Too much of either will make you a crybaby or a robot.
There would be a debate yeah. How would they find out though hehe, I mean the evidence went out the window, literally.