I was browsing interest checks and currently ongoing ropleplays in the Nation Roleplays and as I was looking through a few, this one individual had been harassed by many other members. I was not there as the arguments were taking place and it was not my place to say anything. But instead of actually giving criticism they were outright disrespectful, antagonizing, rude, and hateful. While some were just being trolls, a few actually outright cussed the OP and his work, calling it degrading words and trying to yank his chain.
Criticism: The analysis and judgment of the faults and merits of a literary or artistic work.
If their excuse is criticism, it's an excuse, and a false one. We are an enjoyable community, we are not some popularity club who beats up and kicks out those we do not like, we just ignore them. Sometimes we try and help them, but this community was not made to make people feel like shit.
The reason why I make this report is because one individual didn't feel the need to stop. The member went to other roleplays this individual created and judged him, negatively questioned him to make him feel bad, outright put his works and thoughts down. If you have an opinion of someones works, you don't disrespect them and trash them because they are unrealistic. 90% if not all roleplays on this forum are unrealistic, but that doesn't matter; because we have fun.
Victim: UltikanaRe
Offender: rextremendum
Evidence
Thread Example 1
Thread Example 2
Post Example 1a
Post Example 1b
Post Example 1c
Continuation of harassment
This isn't harmless questioning. I and many others have been victim to this. This is negative judgement, not opinions or concern. They act harmless to go under the moderations radar just to belittle the entire idea.
This user has broken Rules 1 and 2, and definitely has not used common sense or good judgement. There are few rules, but that's because we all should know better. We have no excuses for when we break these rules. If there were hundreds of rules, one being loitering, that would be understandable as no one wants to go through dozens and dozens of rules. But the bottom line being common sense and good judgement, this user had no thought nor care to the standing rules.
It is not my place to speak on the victims behalf, but we've all been there, thinking if we speak out against someone who might be popular we might be bashed. I just don't care, and no one should stand for this kind of behavior.