No, because the punishment comes from nearly failing, and having to learn the lesson as a team. You need to take into consideration that at every turn, you've pushed away our ways of trying to save her. You were in it to win from the start, and wanted us to have literally no way of finding you. It's her character, it's her decision. No one should be able to dictate another character, and if you play the villain you have to take into consideration that you can't be a dictator for the whole role play. You have to be flexible and you have to place the responsibility on yourself to keep it friendly and true.
This is going too far, and it isn't fair.