1 Guest viewing this page
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by clark
Raw
Avatar of clark

clark zero thirty

Member Seen 10 yrs ago

Not sure if this is the appropriate place for it, but it would be nice to have a Steampunk tag as well. And I don't know if the tag system is the best vehicle for this, but it would be nice to have some way to indicate when a game is "hiring" or not. Again, maybe this shouldn't be a tag, but a tag could work.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by Captain Jordan
Raw
Avatar of Captain Jordan

Captain Jordan My other rocket is a car

Member Seen 1 yr ago

<Snipped quote by UltikanaRe> But that would require moderation, and would make filtering impossible. It's easier to have a broad list of tags, fit for most (if not all) circumstances while keeping the list manageable.
I honestly don't think it would require as much work as you think. A report system could be useful here (any word on that, @Mahz?), but simply have a list of banned terms (which would probably include sexually explicit content and whatever stupid things get reported) that cannot be made into tags. Filtering would work best with that auto-complete system that Mahz devised for Co-GM names, apply that same technology to tags and it would be possible to facilitate tag discovery without having to list out all tags, or do those silly tag maps or other awful things. Some popular tags could also be suggested, based on searches or newly-created RPs. These are all suggestions, however, but I think a custom-tag system is not too prohibitive.
Hidden 10 yrs ago 10 yrs ago Post by UltikanaRe
Raw
Avatar of UltikanaRe

UltikanaRe O God Among Gods, O Lord Above All Lords

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

Do you think it will ever be possible for GMs to voluntarily delete/close threads? @Captain Jordan I agree. It is simply impossible to cover every genre, sub-genre, and idea out there. If Mahz trusts us to to report abusive and explicit PMs and posts, why couldn't we report abusive and explicit tags?
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by TheMaster99
Raw
Avatar of TheMaster99

TheMaster99 Benevolent Cyberpunk

Member Seen 1 mo ago

I wasn't saying it'd be hard to do or prohibitive, @Captain Jordan, but I do think it isn't really necessary, and complicates things more than it needs to be. In most cases, a simple list can describe a roleplay well enough for someone to know if they will be interested in more info or not. Of course there will be some niche ones that won't have great tags, but fantasy; fandom, modern, etc should be broad enough to be applicable. Just my two cents.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by LegendBegins
Raw
Avatar of LegendBegins

LegendBegins

Moderator Online

<Snipped quote by TheMaster99> I honestly don't think it would require as much work as you think. A report system could be useful here (any word on that, @Mahz?), but simply have a list of banned terms (which would probably include sexually explicit content and whatever stupid things get reported) that cannot be made into tags. Filtering would work best with that auto-complete system that Mahz devised for Co-GM names, apply that same technology to tags and it would be possible to facilitate tag discovery without having to list out all tags, or do those silly tag maps or other awful things. Some popular tags could also be suggested, based on searches or newly-created RPs. These are all suggestions, however, but I think a custom-tag system is not too prohibitive.
However, many will abuse the system and simply begin to change the spelling, or otherwise modify banned words in order to bypass the filter. People tend to be very creative when doing things they are not allowed to do.
Do you think it will ever be possible for GMs to voluntarily delete/close threads? @Captain Jordan I agree. It is simply impossible to cover every genre, sub-genre, and idea out there. If Mahz trusts us to to report abusive and explicit PMs and posts, why couldn't we report abusive and explicit tags?
I actually think it'd be a horrific experience if a GM could control the existence of a thread. The second a rogue GM arises, then all members involved in the Roleplay would be scattered, and the RP potentially killed, just because a GM decided that he was angry with the members.
Hidden 10 yrs ago 10 yrs ago Post by NuttsnBolts
Raw
Avatar of NuttsnBolts

NuttsnBolts

Moderator Seen 8 days ago

Do you think it will ever be possible for GMs to voluntarily delete/close threads? @Captain Jordan I agree. It is simply impossible to cover every genre, sub-genre, and idea out there. If Mahz trusts us to to report abusive and explicit PMs and posts, why couldn't we report abusive and explicit tags?
From my experience having members with the ability to perform mod like actions is a terrible idea. Even a rogue mod can cause a mountain of problems and stress (I speak from experiencing it when I was once an admin of a site) Imagining that site wide with the members would just be a nightmare. D:
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by Captain Jordan
Raw
Avatar of Captain Jordan

Captain Jordan My other rocket is a car

Member Seen 1 yr ago

However, many will abuse the system and simply begin to change the spelling, or otherwise modify banned words in order to bypass the filter. People tend to be very creative when doing things they are not allowed to do.
Hold the phone! People try to abuse systems? No way! Actually, I thought that's what moderators were for. And ban lists. And rules like "be Fonz cool." Don't overthink it.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by LegendBegins
Raw
Avatar of LegendBegins

LegendBegins

Moderator Online

<Snipped quote by LegendBegins> Hold the phone! People try to abuse systems? No way! Actually, I thought that's what moderators were for. And ban lists. And rules like "be Fonz cool." Don't overthink it.
Sarcasm noted. However, the point is that it's much easier to maintain a whitelist than it is a blacklist.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by UltikanaRe
Raw
Avatar of UltikanaRe

UltikanaRe O God Among Gods, O Lord Above All Lords

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

I mean GMs for their own threads, not for other people's.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by UltikanaRe
Raw
Avatar of UltikanaRe

UltikanaRe O God Among Gods, O Lord Above All Lords

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

True, but I do not think closing a thread would be terrible idea. Also, perhaps there is a way to move closed threads to the back automatically.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by LegendBegins
Raw
Avatar of LegendBegins

LegendBegins

Moderator Online

I mean GMs for their own threads, not for other people's.
True, but I do not think closing a thread would be terrible idea. Also, perhaps there is a way to move closed threads to the back automatically.
I understand that, but do consider that having control over the ability to post entirely reaches the realm of moderator capability, and could be too powerful for a GM. What if he wishes to lock one player out simply because he does not like them? It's an easy system to abuse.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by UltikanaRe
Raw
Avatar of UltikanaRe

UltikanaRe O God Among Gods, O Lord Above All Lords

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

@LegendBegins Magz already maintains that GM word is law, so blocking individuals could be helpful. If you look at every closed thread in the help forum...that could all end.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by Captain Jordan
Raw
Avatar of Captain Jordan

Captain Jordan My other rocket is a car

Member Seen 1 yr ago

It's a conundrum that I pointed out earlier. I'll quote the relevant part of my post here:
Is this something where a mod would be needed? If so, then you have the other consequence of taking the decision out of the GM's hands (and the GM runs the RP, not the mods). If the mods are simply there to carry out the GM's wishes, then what's the point of not allowing the GM to perform that action in the first place? Who has the power here? The GM? The Player? The Mods? Nobody?
If the mods are in charge, then don't give the illusion that the GM's word is law in her/his own roleplay. If the GM's word is law, then they should have the ability to enforce it. Any middle ground is going to cause confusion and hypocrisy.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by LegendBegins
Raw
Avatar of LegendBegins

LegendBegins

Moderator Online

It's a conundrum that I pointed out earlier. I'll quote the relevant part of my post here: <Snipped quote by Captain Jordan> If the mods are in charge, then don't give the illusion that the GM's word is law in her/his own roleplay. If the GM's word is law, then they should have the ability to enforce it. Any middle ground is going to cause confusion and hypocrisy.
Agreed. And I personally believe,@UltikanaRe, that giving GMs the ability to control the forum aspect of their Roleplay can easily lead to the sacrifice of the enjoyment of other players.
Hidden 10 yrs ago 10 yrs ago Post by UltikanaRe
Raw
Avatar of UltikanaRe

UltikanaRe O God Among Gods, O Lord Above All Lords

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

GM powers have long been regarded as a necessary feature. I know of several mod and Mahz quotes supporting it.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by LegendBegins
Raw
Avatar of LegendBegins

LegendBegins

Moderator Online

GM powers have long been regarded as a necessary feature. I know of several mod and Mahz quotes supporting it.
GM Powers do not equal controlling the existence or availability of a thread by any means. I support giving the GM higher options, but I am very much against giving him the ability to completely shut down or lock out the thread. For instance, on my RP, the thread creator (who wasn't me, because he decided to be quick and generate our Roleplay here on his own) left about a year ago after a long fight. If he had the ability to kick us all out and shut down our thread, it would be chaos, especially when he should have had no powers in the first place. Yes, GMs should have special rights, but altering the way the thread acts in the forum should not be one of them.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by UltikanaRe
Raw
Avatar of UltikanaRe

UltikanaRe O God Among Gods, O Lord Above All Lords

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

You could just copy-paste the ICs and make a reboot.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by Mike Wasowski
Raw
Avatar of Mike Wasowski

Mike Wasowski I sacrifice for the ones I love.

Member Seen 7 yrs ago

I'm new here and haven't had all the time in the world to read the features that are planned and such. But I feel like a reputation system would be nice and would help with moderation. And perhaps forum ranks would be cool to have as well. However I really do enjoy the site as is. But since it's up for discussion I figured I might offer a few of my ideas.
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by KeysOfKayes
Raw
Avatar of KeysOfKayes

KeysOfKayes The Worst There Ever Was

Member Seen 7 yrs ago

You could just copy-paste the ICs and make a reboot.
If the thread had been deleted, how are you going to copy+paste anything?
Hidden 10 yrs ago Post by UltikanaRe
Raw
Avatar of UltikanaRe

UltikanaRe O God Among Gods, O Lord Above All Lords

Member Seen 6 yrs ago

I agree total deletion would be troublesome, but closing it would do nothing.
↑ Top
1 Guest viewing this page
© 2007-2024
BBCode Cheatsheet