I have an idea that stemmed from the Lord of the Rings Card Game. Basically, we are characters who are relied upon for all the various jobs, quests, and missions that are important but you never really hear about.
The Hunt for Gollum- At the request of Galadriel, our heroes set out to hunt for Gollum, a mysterious creature that is largely associated with the One Ring. But we are not alone in our hunt, Orc hunters from Mordor are on his trail as well but they aren't all we will find in the Anduin Valley.
The Conflict at Carrock- A scenario stemming off of the search for Gollum. A group of trolls has moved into Carrock and are threatening the livelihood of the Beornings, a race of skin-changers. Enraged, their leader, Grimbeorn the Old, sets out to drive the trolls from his land.
Escape from Moria- At a time, the heroes of the Hobbit Tales had managed to reclaim the great halls of Moria. But things took a turn for the worst and now holding this great underground city seems impossible. Escape seems slightly more probable.
And that's too name a few of the possible stories. Those just kind of work together. Now I'm awful with the lore so I'm fine with following our own path and making our own story, too. I have loads of ideas based on the quests and stuff, too, so there is a lot our characters can do!
This would be very open to suggestions and really any character you want to play. We could play one group or we could even pick up a second group from a different place or timeline, too.