Nigel: *Walks in, holding a movie* Hey, love, I was thinking that you and I could-- *Sees Arlia and Eryn in the same dress and instantly forgets what he was saying* Uh...What, uh...What's going on?
Sean: *Walks in* Yo, Eryn, I just heard about an anime convention in town and-- *Looks at Arlia and Eryn for a few long moments, then turns to Nigel* Which one's yours?
Eryn: *Holds onto Sean and gently strokes his head* Well... Arlia suggested that we try and see if any of you could tell us apart, but I guess I'm just not good at being her at all. ^^;
Arlia: Nonsense! You did a wonderful job, Eryn dear. Perhaps we just need a more... comfortable outfit. *Leans on Nigel's torso*
Hayley: Well, you both can't tell them apart, but can your other sides do that? I would imagine telling them apart by scent is much easier, given that the crazy hag is always drenched in who-knows-what.
Arlia: Excuse me?! I'll have you know that that who-knows-what is an expensive Eau de Cologne! You simply have no taste for an exotic scent!
Hayley: At least I don't go out smelling like I've bathed myself in flower oil!
How about slightly before that, when Nigel receive a 'gift' from Arlia's father after he found out about their relationship? We can say that they have met more often and Papa Medici doesn't like it when he finds out. >:3
Let's just say it's something so vile, I can only describe it in detail through PM, if you're so inclined... It would make any sane man gag in disgust and Nigel burning with untold fury.