<Snipped quote by Hael>
I can't see any difficulty for an industry that can break down entire planets, though.
I can. It's about fairness and keeping the RP the way I want I envisioned it to be.
Also, it takes years and years to break down planets, so that's hardly a fair argument. It's hardly an argument.
Anyways, the point of replicators is small-scale use. If you have enough energy to rely on replicators alone then we long have problems.
And that's fine, but I don't want anyone starting off with it. You should need to develop it over time. If you have replicators and others do not, it would make things extraordinarily unbalanced- even if it's small-scale.
You can create replicators IC, and it should take some time to develop.
This and my idea of replicators are similar. The point is that while making stuff out of energy is nice, it's expensive. E=mc^2 is no joke and that's not even talking about other issues. Rather you use raw materials whenever you can because energy is not for free.
In general:
Traditional construction > Q-Fabs (so long you don't account for versatility thus the latter still dominates in many fields)
Raw materials > Transforming one material to another > creating metamaterials > creating matter out of energy
Replicators using up metastable matter are a kind of compromise. It works for a simple and not too energy consuming versatile creation kit but metastable matter is not cheap. Its benefits are in the simplification of logistics.
Just like how practically every vehicle from ships to airplanes or even tanks within the modern US military uses the same type of fuel. Might not be the most economical but it's an amazing accomplishment regardless.
This is all okay, but I really don't like the idea of anyone starting off with this. It seems O.P. to me, and it's too technologically advanced for what I intend for the start of this RP. This is a lower technological level than even basic replicators.
You can have all of this. But it must be created in-game, and it will take many posts to do so.
I'm not bending on this at all, because it has nothing to do with the viability or realism of replicators, and everything to do with the evenness, style, and vision of this RP.
EDIT: We do have once race with replicators, but there are only 10,000 of them, they have no homeplanet, they will stand there and let you shoot them without resistance, and they have no weaponry of any kind, so I allowed them to have replicators to balance things out, as they are the weakest race in this RP. For anyone else, it would be unfair.