Been wanting to take a quick rant in this thread. And today's my ranting day it seems.
Schools
Less that they're overdone, and more that they're consistently done in the same way over and over. To add to that, I've almost always viewed the default way as a poor way to do them. Of all the cliche templates one can use to create an RP (a top offender being standard tolkienesque fantasy), this one creates the smallest room for stories in my book. It doesn't offer the same degree of narrative freedom in the stories told, the characters it accepts, etc. It's actually quite frustrating because there's been one or two that looked like they had promise but the shortcomings inherent in the genre stifled that.
Schools
Less that they're overdone, and more that they're consistently done in the same way over and over. To add to that, I've almost always viewed the default way as a poor way to do them. Of all the cliche templates one can use to create an RP (a top offender being standard tolkienesque fantasy), this one creates the smallest room for stories in my book. It doesn't offer the same degree of narrative freedom in the stories told, the characters it accepts, etc. It's actually quite frustrating because there's been one or two that looked like they had promise but the shortcomings inherent in the genre stifled that.