I'm still reading it, you guys really went all out. Mad props to you both.
<Snipped quote by Spirit>
Even with a creative approach, Shamir's magic is only good for (at least right now) healing minor wounds and transmutation, and he doesn't seem to have much ranged ability. So the fight would be very up-close and personal, which is where Kyvir accels.
Alexander seems to be capable of some ranged work, with his fire Magic, which would give him (IMO) the best odds against Kyvir depending on the fight's setting. I'd say that Alexander would do best in 50+ meters sized area, but anything less an Kyvir could get close enough to end things pretty quickly.
Garuda would be a quick fight, one way or the other. I'd assume He wouldn't attack Kyvir from a long range, as that would make it easy for Kyvir to dodge the (fairly) small explosive radius. So it'd be mid-close range, which is where they both kick ass, so It'd definitely be the most interesting.
And no I get you, I'm not arguing either.
<Snipped quote by Spirit>
Sorry for double post
Unless Shamir is able to get range on Kyvir, it won't be a very fair fight. Shamir is likely to be a lot faster than Kyvir, but Kyvir is pretty light on his feet for the mountain he is. That, plus Shamir is an "Average" swordsman, whereas Kyvir is only alive because he was the best fighter Surthay could produce. Right now, the only people I'm seeing that could take him on would be Alexander, Garuda, or obviously, Isilfarrel.
However, with that all being said, his greatest weakness is his loyalty. Unless ordered to do otherwise by Isilfarrel, he won't attack or get into fights with people. Even if someone picks a fight with him, he will play it defensively and do little actual damage to them, only doing enough to stop them from continuing to attack him.
<Snipped quote by Spirit>
My final question would put that to bed, actually: should all the students be relatively young (college-aged by human standards) or would it be alright, if a bit odd, that a relatively older character (mid 40's-50's's dwarf) came to join the school?
<Snipped quote by Spirit>
Nah,, I'm gonna try to go Facetank Paladin with magic as more of a booster for his combat skills. He's mostly here to learn about enchanting, because magic gear yo.