I'm debating between Flash(probably the Wally West iteration) or James Todd as Red Hood.

I like the Flash idea but am kinda iffy on the Red Hood idea. Of course if you were to be Walley West he would have to be the first Flash. I'm not saying don't be the Red Hood but you would have to make him his own character with nothing to do with Batman. This is because James Todd was as you know Robin first, and since heroes (including Batman) have only been around for about a month or so that gives us a continuity problem before we even start. However, if you can make him his own person away from Batman I have absolutely no problem with it!

Can we stop calling Jason Todd "James Todd" by the way? I'd appreciate it.

Well Ruby I got to say that's a good character sheet. I really like your arc ideas. One thing though, I'm assuming that Zatanna is just now starting her actual super hero career after taking on Allura? Superheroes just appeared in the last month or so meaning that decade of her travelling and training would be just that. She wouldn't actually be 'heroing' during that time right? If that's the case you are accepted and can put Ms. Zatara in the character section!

I'm debating between Flash(probably the Wally West iteration) or James Todd as Red Hood.

I like the Flash idea but am kinda iffy on the Red Hood idea. Of course if you were to be Walley West he would have to be the first Flash. I'm not saying don't be the Red Hood but you would have to make him his own character with nothing to do with Batman. This is because James Todd was as you know Robin first, and since heroes (including Batman) have only been around for about a month or so that gives us a continuity problem before we even start. However, if you can make him his own person away from Batman I have absolutely no problem with it! *edit Oh and Lovleand, Alan's costume actually looks awesome! I like it.

Wait. I could've done Kara? argh.

Oh, crap. Sorry! I was (mostly) kidding with the Kara crack, not trying to put you in an awkward position.

Oh, crap. Sorry! I was (mostly) kidding with the Kara crack, not trying to put you in an awkward position.

Haha no worries Ruby!

Also villains such as Lex Luthor and the Joker will be played by the player taking on their heroes. (The player playing Batman will have all Batman villains to use in their character's multiple arcs.)

P.S. Is it a flat requirement to fill out the arc pitch section of the CS? I have many arcs to play with John but giving a good three of four of them away seems to spoil the fun somewhat.

Everyone so far has just given a little hook, not described the whole plot, so you don't really have to give away much.

That, and I thought it might be nice to use some lesser known villains.

Well, this is the problem. So far, any hero blocks out a good double-digit number of otherwise fun and interesting characters (that could, by themselves, attract players to the game). Or they restrict themselves. I prefer the latter as more players = a longer-living game, and nothing restricts a writer, only 'encourages innovation', to use some doublespeak.

One thing I think is a little iffy is people writing their own villains. Maybe it would be more interesting if everyone played someone else's villains?

Hmm, interesting idea on the villains. We could certainly do something like that bu it would have to be agreed upon by the player playing the hero in case they want to have full control over their character. Villains could definitely be played as a collab type system though. Great idea Lovleand!